The Top 10 Recipes of 2018

Fill your mealtimes with flavorful favorites from our meal plan service! Our Top 10 Recipes of 2018 include unforgettable dinners like Tuna Poke Bowl and Lasagna Soup.

  • By Brittany Yamamoto-Taylor
  • January 29, 2019

At the beginning of each new year, it’s always exciting to look toward a wide open future and set goals for new things to try. However, in the midst of looking ahead, it’s a great idea to bring some of last year’s best experiences along with you as well.

To help enrich 2019 with your favorite flavors, we put together a list of our 10 best recipes of 2018. (Okay, there are 11 meals, but the last 3 are tied in the same place . . .  And top 10 simply sounds better! 😉 ) This list comes from the feedback and ratings given by our fantastic community for every meal last year. Our rating system is based on 5 stars, with 1 being “Boo, didn’t like it!” and 5 being “This was soooo yummy I want to eat it every day!”.

Find out why these top 10 recipes made the cut! And if you haven’t made these meals yet, they are a great introduction to what we offer as part of our meal plan service.

1. Tuna Poke Bowl | Average Rating 4.92

Hawaiian Poke has become all the rage in the past couple years and, unsurprisingly, our poke bowls are right at the top of our community favorites for the 2nd year in a row. These 30-minute, no-cook bowls ensure dinner gets on the table in a jiffy while still packing all of the refreshing flavors of avocado, edamame, raw fish (or shrimp!), and spicy garlic mayo.

“Absolutely loved it, it was so delicious, flavorful, and easy. Would highly recommend and would definitely make it for guests.”

– Chris K.

2. Sheet Pan Greek Salmon | Average Rating 4.77

With single-sheet-pan roasting and an easy baby kale salad, it’s no surprise this colorful meal is a 2018 favorite. Amidst the seasoned salmon and roasted oregano potatoes, our community found that the secret star of the show is our unique bell pepper and olive salsa. Its delightful flavor flawlessly brings each part of this meal’s Greek inspiration together.

“This was a great meal! It was delicious, and so healthy! I wasn’t expecting to love it (just not my favorite combo of foods usually), but I did! So glad I kept an open mind. The salsa was subtly sweet, and all the flavors blended so well together.”

– Jeanine F.

3. Lasagna Soup | Average Rating 4.72

While classic lasagna is time-consuming to make, our members found the perfect solution in our deconstructed Lasagna Soup recipe! With Italian sausage, ricotta, noodles, mushrooms, and spinach, it’s easy to enjoy all of the heartwarming flavors of lasagna in a fraction of the time.

“This was awesome, my wife loved it and can’t wait to have it again. Tasted like lasagna in soup form!!”

– Jeffrey B.

4. Taco Salad with Ground Turkey | Average Rating 4.69

Whether using seasoned ground turkey or beef, our community sang the praises of this 30-minute taco salad. With fresh veggies, creamy avocados, Mexican cheeses, crunchy tortilla chips, and honey adobo dressing, this meal is a must try.

“I’ve never used ground turkey in a taco salad before and I just loved it! The sauce was amazing and we will definitely be making this again!”

– Catherine R.

5. Steak with Miso-Lime Butter | Average Rating 4.64

We first featured this meal back in 2015 and then brought it back last year because it was such a hit. While our miso-lime butter is the true star of the show, many of our community members (even kids!) found a new love of bok choy through this delicious recipe as well.

“Miso lime butter is the stuff of dreams. I want to put it on everything. Amazing!”

Amanda G.

6. Buttermilk Pancakes | Average Rating 4.64

Another top recipe of 2018 is the indulgent brunch (or breakfast-for-dinner) that gave our community members one more thing to celebrate during the holidays. After all, it rarely gets better than buttermilk pancakes with a ham, spinach, and tater tot egg-bake!

“Definitely the best tasting pancake and egg bake recipe I’ve ever made!! The entire family gobbled it up.”

– Lorra J.

7. Caprese Naan Pizzas | Average Rating 4.63

In 7th place are our Italian-inspired naan pizzas that are topped with mozzarella, basil pesto, and fresh tomatoes. With delicious grilled peaches and zucchini on the side, our members loved how this pizza came together with delightful flavors and effortless finesse.

“This was a super easy meal to make. I was skeptical of adding the peaches, but man, they were a great addition!”

– Becky C.

8. Shrimp Tacos with Chimichurri | Average Rating 4.62

With a chimichurri sauce and tangy corn and black bean salsa, these shrimp tacos had our community thinking about making these again the moment they finished dinner!

“The spice mix on the shrimp was outstanding! My husband ate three tacos and then moaned about how full he was, but that he wanted me to make it again next week. Excellent!”

– Susan T.

9. Balsamic Chicken & Spinach Salad, Cajun Shrimp Po’ Boy, & Slow Cooker Sopa Azteca with Chicken | Average Rating 4.61

Finishing our 2018 favorites is a 3-way tie between our Balsamic Chicken & Spinach Salad, Cajun Shrimp Po’ Boy, and Slow Cooker Sopa Azteca. Our Cook Smarts members simply raved about the flavors in these meals that only take 25 minutes of active cooking! Though simple to make, all three dishes stand out with amazing flavor, thanks to a homemade vinaigrette, Cajun spices, and slow simmering.

“This is a super easy recipe that’s eaten by everyone in the family, including my picky 11 and 13 year old girls. Any recipe that is gobbled down by all of the family members is a winner to me! I added this to our favorites, as I’m always looking for easy, ‘go to’ salad recipes.”

– Kara G.

“Loved the ease of the recipe. I had everything on hand. Big hit all around! Definitely will make again.”

– Nancy H.

“Oh man, this soup was so good, and I don’t usually care for soup that much. And it was pretty simple to throw together on a weeknight. This will definitely go in my regular rotation for the upcoming winter months.”

– Jenn S.

Now that you’ve heard about 2018’s mouth-watering favorites, you’ll be thrilled to know that all of these recipes (in all 4 versions, which includes Gluten-Free, Vegetarian, and Paleo!) are a part of our recipe archives. While you continue to receive delectable meals and ingenious tools from us each week, make sure you revisit last year’s hits as well to make 2019 your most delicious year yet!

If one of your favorite recipes of 2018 wasn’t included in this list, let us know what meal you’ll be bringing back this year in the comments below.

Not a part of our community yet? For only $6 / month, you can enjoy hundreds of tried-and true meals, get a new savvy meal plan each week, reduce food waste, and save countless hours and dollars this year by making one very smart choice:

We want to see your cooking! If you make any of the meals above, be sure to tag us #cooksmarts on Instagram, so we can see your delicious food photos!

As always, we’re here to help you live your best life in the kitchen and provide delicious memories for you and your family. If you sign up for our newsletter below, we’ll send you great cooking tips and resources that will help you raise your kitchen IQ and cook with confidence.

Cook Smarts Top 10 Meal Plan Recipes of 2018Cook Smarts Top 10 Meal Plan Recipes of 2018


Try our award winning meal plan service for free

Get our Meal Plans

The convenience of meal kits without the waste

Share the love!

Join our community

Enjoy free tips in your inbox

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
How can we help you in the kitchen?

Join our community

Enjoy free tips in your inbox

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Sign up for the Cook Smarts Newsletter

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.


Privacy Policy: We hate SPAM & promise to keep your email address safe.

Skip to content