Store-Bought vs Homemade Stock


Is it stock or broth? Stock indicates that bones were used; broth is not made with bones. However, these days, I see people using them interchangeably all the time, so don’t sweat the nomenclature.

In my kitchen, I typically use all three options: store bought stocks and broths, bouillon, and homemade.

One of my biggest pet peeves is when professional or TV chefs say, “Everyone should make their own stock. It’s so easy.” And yes, while I believe that making your own stock is an easy skill to learn, I definitely don’t feel guilty when I opt for a more convenient option.

If I was spending all day in a kitchen and my sole job was to cook, I’d always have homemade stock on hand. However, our lives are crazy and hectic, and I believe in giving myself a break. Anyhow, my point is. . .

Do not ever let anyone make you feel guilty about not doing it from scratch.

This is how I use the three different options:


1. Canned and boxed stocks and broths:

This is my go-to option for weeknight dinners and forms the base of curry sauces, stir-fry sauces, quick soups, and risottos. I also use it when sautéing vegetables and want to add some more flavor. If your pan ever looks too dry, add a glug of pre-made stock, and your dish will be rescued from burning.

I love Swanson’s chicken stock and buy in bulk at Costco. For vegetable broth and beef stock, I typically use Trader Joe’s, mostly because that’s where I shop for my pantry essentials.

2. Bouillon:

One of my cooking students introduced me to Better Than Bouillon last year. Instead of the compact powdered cubes, this is a concentrated paste. I use this when making “chicken rice” without the chicken. I cook rice as I normally do but just add a few scoops of this into the water. The result: really flavorful rice.

I also use it to add needed flavor to soups that may not have started with a stock base. I realize it’s not the healthiest (I do buy the low-sodium version), but I use it sparingly and you only need a little for a lot of flavor.

3. Homemade stock and broth:

If I have homemade on hand, it’s what I’ll reach for first when a meal calls for it. However, I don’t ever make a point to make stock. It usually happens if I’ve bought a rotisserie chicken and have bones on hand or if I’ve bought shell-on shrimp and need to discard the uncooked shells anyway. Those stock-bases get thrown into a pot of water with onions, carrots, and celery added, and I boil away.

However, if I’m too lazy or don’t have the rest of the stock ingredients on hand, I’ll put the bones or food scraps into a bag and freeze it until I find the motivation or have the other ingredients available.


Stock or broth is one of the most common ingredients I use in my cooking, and I want to know what you do in your kitchen when it comes to this pantry essential, so share with the Cook Smarts community in the comments below. I’d love to know what you do and if there are some creative ideas you have for stock or broth!


Join our community

Enjoy free tips in your inbox

Tags: , , , ,
  • Laurie

    I’ve been making my own chicken stock for a couple years now from scraps – its essentially free. I started buying whole chickens to save money when I switched to organic meats and decided to keep the bones for stock to make our purchase stretch a little farther. Recently, I read to save all the “unusable” portions of your celery, onions, and carrots and throw those in when you boil your chicken bones to make it even more free – no need to purchase the veggies when you have saved up the ends of onions, carrots and celery that would normally be thrown away! I also keep an eye on parsley and other fresh herbs in the fridge and when they might go bad I throw them in with the stock veggies in the freezer. This has made my stock production a wonderful thrifty addition to my food production endeavors. I love throwing it in a crock pot all day and coming home to a house filled with the smell of chicken soup!

    PS I love your food blog and meal plans! Thanks!

  • https://www.cooksmarts.com Jess

    Laurie, Thanks so much for sharing. You are amazingly resourceful in the kitchen, and I wish I was as diligent as you are. I also keep a few stock bags in my freezer, but I need to get better about just saving carrot shavings, the ends of celery and onions, as well as almost-spoiled herbs like you have. Thank you for the inspiration. Also, so glad you love this blog and meal plans. I love readers like you!

  • https://markellandjason.wordpress.com markelll

    My husband came up with a system that sounds similar to Laurie’s, except we make veggie broth. We keep a bag in the freezer and throw in fennel fronds, leek tops, and parsley stems throughout the month. Whenever it’s full (and we have the time), we throw it all in a BIG pot of water, with a few carrots to balance the flavor, and let it simmer for several hours. We end up with usually about 8 quarts of essentially free veggie broth. And it makes a great base for soups or anything recipe that calls for stock/broth.

  • https://www.cooksmarts.com Jess

    Thanks Markell for sharing (and also being my BFF). I just started a new stock bag of veggie scraps after inspiration from both yours and Laurie’s comments!

Recommended Reads

Discover a smarter and happier way to cook

Get Started

Jess Dang

Jess Dang is the Founder of Cook Smarts where she also wears the hat of Chief Kitchen Coach. She left the corporate world in 2011 to start Cook Smarts because she was passionate about bringing food education back to our schools and family dinners back into our lives. Follow me here

View Comments

  • I've been making my own chicken stock for a couple years now from scraps - its essentially free. I started buying whole chickens to save money when I switched to organic meats and decided to keep the bones for stock to make our purchase stretch a little farther. Recently, I read to save all the "unusable" portions of your celery, onions, and carrots and throw those in when you boil your chicken bones to make it even more free - no need to purchase the veggies when you have saved up the ends of onions, carrots and celery that would normally be thrown away! I also keep an eye on parsley and other fresh herbs in the fridge and when they might go bad I throw them in with the stock veggies in the freezer. This has made my stock production a wonderful thrifty addition to my food production endeavors. I love throwing it in a crock pot all day and coming home to a house filled with the smell of chicken soup!

    PS I love your food blog and meal plans! Thanks!

    • Laurie, Thanks so much for sharing. You are amazingly resourceful in the kitchen, and I wish I was as diligent as you are. I also keep a few stock bags in my freezer, but I need to get better about just saving carrot shavings, the ends of celery and onions, as well as almost-spoiled herbs like you have. Thank you for the inspiration. Also, so glad you love this blog and meal plans. I love readers like you!

  • My husband came up with a system that sounds similar to Laurie's, except we make veggie broth. We keep a bag in the freezer and throw in fennel fronds, leek tops, and parsley stems throughout the month. Whenever it's full (and we have the time), we throw it all in a BIG pot of water, with a few carrots to balance the flavor, and let it simmer for several hours. We end up with usually about 8 quarts of essentially free veggie broth. And it makes a great base for soups or anything recipe that calls for stock/broth.

    • Thanks Markell for sharing (and also being my BFF). I just started a new stock bag of veggie scraps after inspiration from both yours and Laurie's comments!

Share
Published by
Jess Dang